CRISPR-Cas9: Becoming a superman, but at what cost?

What is CRISPR and how does it work?

Let’s say you have an appointment with your doctor today. You show up, he greets you and casually explains that you have a cancerous tumor. Is it concerning? Of course not, the doctor is just going to extract some of your cells, modify them and inject everything back in your body. It is simple, cheap, fast, and almost painless. Cancer has become a minor inconvenience.

This might be our near future if CRISPR-Cas9 delivers all its promises. This revolutionary gene-editing tool is now used and enhanced by many actors in the pharmaceutical industry. And curing diseases is only a small part of what gene editing can do to change our lives.

What is CRISPR-Cas9 ?

A close up of a map

Description automatically generated Marie Minet, a PHD student at the Institute of Human Genetics, Saarland University, Germany explains CRISPR-Cas9 as such: Cas9 is a specific enzyme found in bacteria and archaea; this enzyme induces breaks in the DNA following the instructions of CRISPR. The cell machinery then repairs the DNA. In short, Cas9 is a DNA-breaking tool guided by CRISPR.

Editing genomes can sound complicated at first, but the technology behind CRISPR-Cas9 is surprisingly simple. CRISPR (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats) are DNA sequences in the genomes of prokaryotic organisms such as bacteria. They are able to find and suppress DNA from similar bacteriophages during infections. Cas9 is an enzyme that uses CRISPR sequences as a guide to recognize and cleave specific strands of DNA that are complementary to the CRISPR sequence.

Together, CRISPR-Cas9 becomes a powerful tool to edit genes in a living organism, including humans. It is a molecular “scissor” that we can use with incredible precision to cut a part of the DNA and replace it by another sequence of our choice.

Historical review

            Other tools allowing gene editing already existed before CRISPR-cas9. Since the 1970s, different methods were developed to add genetic elements to living organisms. Up to this day, no method is 100% effective and the randomness of the insertion of the DNA in the genome makes it hard to find a reliable way of doing it. CRISPR is a true revolution in this domain, as it is a cheap and quite reliable way of editing genes. It is about four times more efficient than TALENS, the previous best genome-editing tool.


The low price of CRISPR made for the first time a powerful and reliable tool for gene edition accessible to the public. With little equipment and a really strong interest in biology and chemistry, basically anyone can experiment DNA modification. This gave birth to an online network of self-taught scientists who call themselves “Biohackers”. From all around the world, they share their experiments through social media as well as advice and materials. The movement first started at MIT about 15 years ago and exploded around 2016, reaching more and more fellows found of science, mainly under the impulse of Josiah Zayner (who since then became the CEO of The Odin).
We’ve come to meet ‘Rick’, a student in chemistry and biohacker since 2016, who used to make a personal lab out of a room of his apartment. As he lives in France – where gene editing is illegal, unlike in the US where most biohackers live – he asked us to use this nickname to preserve his anonymity.  Even though he admits that it can be pretty dangerous to play with science, he is really proud of what he learned throughout his experiments.

What are the possible applications it could have?

            It is difficult to realize the number of applications this tool can have. Curing diseases is one of the most discussed ones, as many genetic diseases could be eradicated. Cancer, AIDS, muscular dystrophy, blood disorders and even some cases of blindness might be curable thanks to CRISPR. But this is only a small part of what this tool is capable of. Anything with a DNA can be modified using CRISPR.

What the biohackers did

Photo credit : David Ishee

           Rick modified bacteria to make it resistant to a certain antibiotic, as an experiment. He also managed to turn some yeast, grown in a petri dish, into a bioluminescent version of itself by modifying its gene sequence thanks to CRISPR-cas9. He admits that it wouldn’t have been possible without the help of the community, especially his “sensei” (Japanese word for instructor) David Ishee. The members share the progress of their even more ambitious projects; making a bioluminescent plant, or even a dog. As scary as it sounds, Rick assures that no wrong is done to any animal nor human, as the people who do this kind of experiment only work with embryo cells and the bioluminescent feature is absolutely painless. They also work for the purpose of learning and make science evolve without all the restrictions that are imposed in the research world. Some of them even go as far as modifying their own genes, to help muscle grow by itself or regenerate their skin cells for example.

What could be done

            Turning yourself into a superhero is also a promise CRISPR should deliver. Keeping some resistance to a disease like Alzheimer’s, getting rid of lactose intolerance or even modifying mosquitoes’ DNA to make females become sterile and thus eradicating malaria might give a better future for the next generations. According to Rick the possibilities of CRISPR-Cas9 are limitless in the future. He gives us the following examples ;

– Using the gene knockout technic to switch on and off the genes expressions to study their roles in the cells

– Inserting more copies of P53 protein into human DNA when it is at the embryo stage resulting in more human resistance to cancer

– Removing Myostatin or Inserting Follistatin to cattle for a better metabolism ; more muscle and less fat

– Designing better crops (Increasing RuBisCo CO2 fixation efficiency or vitamin nutrition)

– Reactivating telomerase in the old multicellular cells resulting in younger cells, increasing life expectancy for humans and animals

– Designing an embryo to make a baby immune to disease, taller, stronger, or even smarter

If we go a bit further, it is quite easy to imagine a society where parents can choose exactly what their children will look like. The personalization of our children, like video-games characters, might become the norm in future societies.

“The question is not what we “could” but what we “should” or “should not” ’ 

– Rick

Which ethical questions should it imply?

This does raise ethical questions. But in a way, the Pandora box is already open, and there is little we can do about it. The biohacker community is raising, and tests on humans have already taken place in regular laboratories in a view to treat advanced cancers.
Which mother is going to refuse to edit genes on their child during pregnancy if it is the only way to save it from being still-born or handicapped? This topic will probably be debated extensively in many countries, which could force some governments to keep gene editing illegal, as it currently is in France.  Some will say it is not ’natural’, others will argue that we cannot decide of fundamental changes for future generations. Even more concerning: if we reach total control over the appearance and the personality of newborns, aren’t we going to lose the diversity that defines humanity? 

Marie Minet shares the most widespread ethical state of mind in the scientific field. She indeed thinks that the tools to modify DNA are too openly available and it broadens the possibility of misuses, especially when it comes to human genetics. Dr. Jiankui’s case (see later) is the perfect example of something which can be interpreted as a misuse because he chose to undergo a procedure on embryos without a genetic disease at a time where all the consequences couldn’t all be known. What Mrs. Minet calls for is an improvement and clarification in the legislation surrounding CRISPR-Cas9 regarding embryos and germinal cells.

“Given that we do not know all the consequences of such modifications of human embryos, and that we know that the CRISPR-Cas9 system produces off-targets (modifications of the DNA that were not intended), I believe it necessary to implement an embargo on the modification of germinal cells (cells producing oocytes or sperm cells) and of embryos destined to implantation in future mothers.”

– Marie MINET

The regulations she advises are targeted at the major ethical conundrum CRISPR-Cas9 poses, but she does not believe that such a strong regulation should be applied to all uses of CRISPR-Cas9: indeed, allowing the clinical experiments of the modification of somatic cells (i.e. not germinal cells) in the case of gene therapies could be beneficial, particularly if it becomes available to a broader public.

Regarding this last aspect, Rick, our biohacker who claims to be in favor of the democratization of CRISPR rather than its regulation, perceives the fear of the public and the scientific community as a conservatist behavior. He mentions how humans actually already performed genetic engineering throughout history, like the agricultural selection for decades and the random mutations caused by radiations or termination of pregnancy in case of trisomy 21.

“Those are also genetic engineering techniques just like CRISPR.”

– Rick

The Chinese experiment

The Chinese researcher He Jiankui claimed to have used gene editing in an embryo before implanting it into the mother´s womb. The aim of this experiment was to make babies resistant to HIV infection. This action took place in 2018, and the twins were born in November of the same year.

Dr. He’s experiment consisted in recruiting couples where the man was infected with HIV, modifying the embryos with Crispr-Cas9 and finally introducing them by in-vitro techniques. The aim was to create human embryos that were resistant to the virus that causes AIDS. The success arrived when two twins were born and there were no visible side effects on other genes. Later, in an interview with the Associated Press, Dr. He explained himself.  “I feel a strong responsibility that it’s not just to make a first, but also make it an example. […] Society will decide what to do next.”. Jiankui was not supported by his colleagues and by the hospital where he made his experience. Dr. Mitalipov (director of the Center for Embryonic Cell and Gene Therapy at Oregon Health and Science University) stated that there are different ways of treating HIV infection in newborns. Furthermore, Shenzhen Harmonicare denied being involved and giving permission to carry out the research. In addition, Jiankui’s attached University (Southern University of Science and Technology), claimed that Dr. He´s work “is a serious violation of academic ethics and academic norms,” according to the state-run Beijing News.  

Regarding legal background, it is not forbidden in China to do so, but only for “non-reproductive purposes”, even though researchers in this country are against these techniques. Nevertheless, by the end of 2019, Shenzhen Court sentenced Dr. He to three years in prison for « illegally carrying out the human embryo gene-editing intended for reproduction”. Two of his colleagues had also been sentenced. The controversy has not ended yet, as Xinhua news agency claims that a third gene-edited baby was born, as a result of He´s experiment. The agency finally stated that the researchers acted « […] in the pursuit of personal fame and gain […] » and seriously « […] disrupted medical order […] ».

Another risk is linked to the entities controlling this tool. Giving even more control over our lives to governments like the Chinese one is concerning to say the least. The Chinese government already had a birth control program for a few decades. What if they impose some DNA sequences to new children, to make sure the sex-ratio is preserved? What if they want to keep a unified population and thus impose a certain DNA to Uighur populations in order to tackle communities? These ideas might seem extreme, but past events show that a tool giving so much control over births is dangerous. Just thinking about what Hitler could have done with such tools to accomplish his Arian dream sends shivers down your spine.  

Crispr in the epidemic crisis of today

In the near future, CRISPR and other gene-editing tools will probably be harshly criticized and rejected by the population. These are scary and quite technical tools, closer to sci-fi movies than to real life. Among others, the fear of a hidden disease induced by these techniques is emphasized by the recent COVID-19 pandemic.

Right now, CRISPR is making a name of itself again, as it could be helpful to fight against the Corona-virus. According to Le Monde (28 March 2020), a new test, made to detect the COVID-19, is based on CRISPR. Scientists were adapting their methods to collect samples of DNA attacked by the virus. This could lead us to sequence accurately the virus, but more importantly instantly, and therefore improve our knowledges about it. According to the National Public Radio (NPR, 17th April 2020), CRISPR is the solution to do faster, cheaper and easier tests. This test, developed by the San Francisco Medical School and Mammoths Bioscience, is self-contained and can be used from anywhere, without any medical equipment.

The ethical dilemma around CRISPR is only at its beginning, as this tool is already powerful and will inevitably continue improving. Every day, a new experiment is made and new targets are edited. Who is authorized to decide the path forward for drastically altering human life, and on what ground? For Dr. He, only his colleagues and the government were involved. Public dialogue led by scientists and bioethicists seeks to affirm scientific experts as the legitimate arbitrators of scientific and technical ethics, and delegates decision-making to those doing the experiences. Yet it is important to expand the number of people in the debate to establish a future with gene editing being beneficial for us all.

19 095 commentaires

    1. Given that mutations in KRAS initiate and drive all stages of pancreatic tumorigenesis 35, 36, it will be of great interest to identify the mechanisms by which a quantitative change in KRAS output can contribute to such dramatic phenotypic and transcriptional differences during tumor progression priligy review members

    1. Honey and Coconut Oil order cialis Gregory instinctively felt the power of the Black Knight, and it immediately hid behind Feng Yue, There was a huge cave ten meters above the does lisinopril cause hot flashes ground, does lisinopril cause hot flashes The villagers were all scrambling to run to the cave

    1. And the rune on the chain looks brighter, it seems that it should be better resistance, and the energy is rising at any time is cialis generic For this reason we hope that patients choose to take us up on our offer to match any advertised prices for the supplements we sell

    1. This study was undertaken at the Melbourne Sexual Health Centre MSHC between March 2005 and November 2007 discreet cialis meds If you had cancer in the past, you also may be at higher risk of severe COVID 19, and you may want to discuss your concerns about COVID 19 with your doctors

    1. Therefore, he put down the air of the son of the grand duke along the way, and paid attention to Rogge, It is a terrible apple cider vinegar pills blood pressure thing to be against such people, What she didn t know was that although Rogge was not mediocre and incompetent, he was greedy for money and lust 60mg priligy

      1. The date of the new prescription or dose change was the intensification date comprare cialis online 1, 2 VHL germline mutations are responsible for the development of highly vascular tumors including hemangioblastomas of the retina and central nervous system, pheochromocytomas and renal cell carcinomas RCC

    1. Patients who have abnormalities in one of these tests should be counseled on the possibility of decreased success rates after tubal reversal clomid for pregnancy The detection of a positive correlation with the alpha catenin signature is used to categorize a tumor as high risk and an appropriate therapy is thus administered and the signature can further be used over time to monitor the chosen therapy

    2. cialis online without The authors of the study speculate that the observed effects of resveratrol may reduce the stress factors that lead to strokes in diabetics and opened the possibility that resveratrol could be a potential agent used to prevent brain dysfunction and reduce stroke risk in diabetics

    3. priligy cvs com 20 E2 AD 90 20Remplacer 20Le 20Viagra 20 20Acheter 20Viagra 20Belgique 20Sans 20Ordonnance remplacer le viagra In addition to signaling displeasure with officials in Moscow, the arrest of those traveling and the warning to those still at large send a message that major Russian criminals should not relax, and that could serve as a deterrent to others, he said

    1. In general, enclomiphene citrate had few changes in these hormones and markers, with the exception of IGF- 1 viagra triangle The study found that OS group and EID group showed a significant decrease in pregnancy rate and the expression of both endometrial leukaemia inhibitory factor LIF and integrin ОІ3 subunit during the implantation window

    1. Secondary outcomes for the baby were perinatal fetal newborn death, including miscarriage, respiratory distress syndrome or respiratory support, and neonatal seizures tadalista vs cialis insulin or oral diabetes medicine; or heart or blood pressure medicine clonidine, digitalis, digoxin, diltiazem, reserpine, or verapamil

    1. It is very rare and appears at birth or soon after where to buy clomid in metres We outlined central it regulates blood sugar levels weight problems as a waist circumference of ninety cm or greater for males and 80 cm or higher How To Reduce Blood Sugar Level Immediately mg dl in blood sugar for women

    1. Although censoring patients at this point might have its limitations, our outcomes also have the advantage that they are based on the real world data and represent the consequences of the therapeutic strategy of tamoxifen and aromatase inhibitors buying cialis online usa Both in vitro and in vivo biological evaluation of the tamoxifen chelates indicated very limited estrogen receptor binding

    1. She continued to take the drug and 10 days later was hospitalized for odynophagia and dehydration cialis pills for sale Furthermore, had a single EM in the antibiotic arm been missed due to patient dropout, then the statistical significance of the primary outcome would have been lost p 0

    1. In an open label randomized trial, use of a Coriolus based vaginal gel had clinical benefit over watchful waiting for patients with HPV related low grade cervical lesions 31 buy cialis online without prescription RenГ© Redzepi at Noma, in Copenhagen, is king of the new wave of Scandinavian cooks, known as New Nordic, and we see his influence and imitators all over the world

    2. In embodiment xvi R 1 is a 2 substituted 3 furyl group of the formula instructions for clomid 6 Anita Monteith, of the Institute of Chartered Accountants, said This adds considerable complication to the tax system for ordinary people, particularly for those brought into the self- assessment system for the first time

    1. Right off the bat, I signed up for the loyalty program, so SingleCare gave me a 5 off coupon cialis pills With stress, antibiotics, and processed dog food being ever present factors, it is crucial to supplement your dog s diet with it continually

    1. Patients should be advised to avoid future use of the drug in order to prevent the potential detrimental effects of thrombocytopenia metformin and clomid I can t go on, Since I came metoprolol and grapefruit juice to defect to you, I will naturally help you, Do you need such a serious person

    2. As another non limiting example, synthetic immune response modifiers including, but not limited to, Tucaresol 4 2 formyl 3 hydroxy phenoxymethyl benzoic acid and its derivatives, and Isotucaresol and its derivatives can form Schiff base adducts with T cell surface amines and, in the presence of an antigen, provides co stimulatory signals to CD4 T cells, enhancing Th cell priming and CD8 cytotoxic T cell priming; leading to favorable therapeutic activity profiles in vivo 2 7 cronadyn vs priligy 2020 May 6; 11 233

    1. Tam tamoxifen, AIs aromatase inhibitors, ER estrogen receptor, ESO ESMO European School of Oncology European School of Medical Oncology, HER2 human epidermal growth factor receptor 2, ESR1 estrogen receptor gene, WT wild type, NGS next generation sequencing, PDX patient derived xenograft, HBD hormone binding domain, TCGA The Cancer Genome Atlas, FISH fluorescent in situ hybridization, ddPCR droplet digital polymerase chain reaction, PR progesterone receptor, DES diethylstilbestrol, cfDNA cell free deoxyribonucleic acid, MBC metastatic breast cancer, CTCs circulating tumor cells, SERM selective estrogen receptor modulator, SERD selective estrogen receptor degrader, SSH SERM SERD hybrid, IC50 half maximal inhibitory concentration ciproflaxin

    1. 3 Complications rarely occur in infants and children; they also are rare in adults since most ASDs close on their own or are repaired in early childhood can tamoxifen cause cancer It is not that Zhao Ling is ruthless, because if they do not follow him after he has revealed his identity, he will naturally report his identity to the bull demon clan chief

    1. Recruitment and retention into such a trial with prolonged participation and delayed treatment may be difficult stromectol crema Using stereotaxic equipment, chemical demyelination was induced in the white matter tract of the corpus callosum at the following coordinates AP 1

    2. There is, however, a small cohort of patients who may experience a clinically significant deterioration in renal function and this highlights the need for baseline measurement and meticulous monitoring and follow up by someone with specific expertise in managing heart failure and acute kidney injury nolvadex tamoxifen for sale uk One user who requested to remain anonymous told Health24 that there are always steroid pushers at the gyms, especially the larger ones

    1. Google Ads is a huge tool for digital marketers, and the Customer Match feature allows you to use your email list to customize your message to specific audiences as needed buy real cialis online The first question that must be asked is whether the client is compliant with ML administration and testing

    1. Transdermal preparations are known to provide very stable and effective improvements in serum T levels due to their pharmacokinetic profile which mimics physiological diurnal variations cialis from india They have also been used in patients undergoing transplantation whose tumor burden exceeds the Milan criteria

    1. Half of the mice with doxycycline inducible Trex1 in TSA cells TSA KI Trex1 in the irradiated tumour and parental TSA TSA WT in the abscopal tumour were given doxycycline and all mice were then treated with 8GyX3 and anti CTLA4 a, b or anti PD 1 c, d where to buy cialis

    1. We describe a case of BS diagnosed as type I through genetic analysis that produced a diuretic loading test result apparently inconsistent with this diagnosis clomiphene antiestrogen In contrast, previous fate mapping in neonatal GFAP CreER T2 mice indicated that neurons that express DCX are generated postnatally from GFAP neural stem cells in SVZ Ganat et al

    2. All the groups that received the carbohydrate supplement had higher blood glucose levels and completed dr gundry blood sugar the does nitrofurantoin increase blood sugar levels 10 kilometer trial faster than the group receiving only how to measure blood sugar level at home Symptoms Of Low Blood Sugar water buy clomid online zest creative

    1. mefenamic acid levofloxacina 500 mg venezuela AstraZeneca said it would pay an intial 200 million plus afurther 240 million if Spirogen meets development targets cialis prices Although her anxiety and depression were relatively well controlled on fluoxetine prior to her cancer diagnosis, a switch from fluoxetine to a selective serotonin norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors such as venlafaxine was recommended, given fluoxetine cytochrome P 450 CYP 2D6 strong inhibition in the conversion of tamoxifen the pro drug to endoxifen the active metabolite

    1. pepcid minoxidil shampoo cvs On a night when the public was finally turning its attention to a sport that has mostly lived on the margins, fans got a taste of why so many have turned their backs on it in recent years because of the head scratching decisions by either corrupt or incompetent judges that continue to mar big fights generic cialis 5mg

    1. Other than changing body shape, I could easily have been one of the I didn t know I was pregnant women up until 22 weeks I felt perfectly normal, except that my pants didn t fit clomiphene antiestrogen Clomiphene citrate plus tamoxifen versus clomiphene citrate Clinical pregnancy rate

  1. 892

    1. Unfortunately, these drugs present serious challenges to the overall health and welfare of the patients, which requires sound support therapies from Complementary and Integrative Medicine to counter side effects, support metabolic systems that will probably be damaged, and enhance the specific effects that we want to see from these drugs who manufactures stromectol

  2. Консультация психолога онлайн.
    Услуги психолога Приглашаем вас на консультации детского психолога.

    Приглашаем вас на консультации детского психолога.

    Сімейні консультації. Заказать консультацию психолога.
    Консультация психолога в Киеве Консультация по

  3. Антъни Джошуа ще заработи 17,5 млн. евро за боя с Александър Усик в събота на стадион „Тотнъм » в Лондон, разкриха британският таблоид „Мирър ». Сумата е с 50 процента повече от Усик Джошуа смотреть онлайн Хирн: «Джошуа нокаутирует Усика»

  4. Джошуа зупинить його за 5-7 раундів. Усик почне швидко, а Ентоні буде трохи обачним, бо Олександр – лівша, і він легший. До того ж Джошуа іноді не вистачає впевненості в боях, в яких його можуть Oleksandr Usyk — Anthony Joshua. Boxing Онлайн новини боксу сьогодні | Останні новини професійного

    1. It s sometimes hard to get someone to answer the phone, but that is only because of how busy the clinic is cialis daily There were equal reductions in hot flashes for all of these groups with a mean reduction in hot flash score for those on tamoxifen or an AI of 7

    1. The enteral route is the mainstay of nutritional support in the critically ill but it is frequently associated with gastrointestinal intolerance and underfeeding buy cialis 5mg 14 Surgeons must not lower the clinical requirements for performing this procedure simply because the patient or the patient s referring physician perceives it to be safer Figure

    1. The MVLN cell line was established in our laboratory from MCF 7 cells by stable transfection with the luciferase gene under the control of an estrogen responsive element from the Xenopus vitellogenin A2 gene generic 5 mg cialis The ISO IEC 17025 requirements accreditation is the prerequisite condition to WADA accreditation