Ethical reflections on immortality

Do you want to live longer? You can, in 2030 or 2040. Tomorrow, then. Today, science is trying to answer that wish. If you think about it longer, wanting to live longer might seem unhealthy. Why is it unhealthy? Why are we not comfortable with this idea of not dying? Do we really have to wish for this? We are indeed talking about eradicating death. There are 3 ways to die: accidents, diseases and old age. For accidents, technology tries to reduce the death rate thanks to the autonomous car for example. For diseases, science fights them by inventing methods and solutions (surgery and vaccines for example). However, for death in natural old age, science can hardly do anything about it. This is where the idea of increasing life expectancy comes into play. It focuses mainly on detecting a disease earlier thanks to technology. For example, in the case of cancer, we could in a few years’ time determine a future cancer that will appear at the age of 50, to a 20-year-old patient. To do this, the methods consist roughly of taking pieces of genes in order to obtain the patient’s coding. These are very complex and expensive techniques, financed by large investors and companies. Because they are expensive, it is likely that some people will have access to them and some people won’t. This will, of course, increase inequalities. This major debate involves many actors and underlying issues. Beyond the questions concerning money, companies and the interest of the project, we would like to focus on its ethical aspect. Is it ethical to increase life? Is it biologically healthy? Can we extend life in a religious point of view? In order to enlighten us, we met two people with very different lives; a doctor, Pauline Zelli, and a rabbi, Nissim Sultan.

Who are the protagonists?

One of the companies that are more engaged in researches related to life expectancy is Google. In recent years, Google has become one of the main sponsors of the transhumanist movement, notably through the massive financial support of companies involved in nanotechnology, biotechnology, computer and cognitive sciences (NBIC). Google’s president (Bill Maris), has also created a company, Calico (Californian Life Corporation), whose goal is to fight against aging and increase human life expectancy. Calico is headed by Arthur Levinson, a biologist who also sits on the Board of Directors of Apple and the pharmaceutical company Hoffmann-La Roche, which runs the US biotech company Genentech. When Calico was founded in 2012, it hired Raymond Kurzweil, a specialist in artificial intelligence, theorist of transhumanism and co-founder of Singularity University, which is also financially sponsored by Google. This university advocates the concept of technological singularity, i.e. the advent of an artificial intelligence that will « exceed » the capacities of the human brain. But Google is not the only one interested in the subject. For more than ten years, multiple companies and billionaires are investing in startups and research centers. Start-ups are embarking on blood transfusions from young patients to older people in an effort to prolong life. Large fortunes or multinationals (like Google-Alphabet) are investing in biotechnologies to identify longevity genes and slow aging. Others are conducting experiments to duplicate the brain in machines. The cryopreservation industry, freezing an organism while waiting for a hypothetical cure for death, is also enjoying a growing success. All share the transhumanist ambition: to create a human being with tenfold longevity, even immortal. Beyond financial interests, there is a real desire to improve the human condition. This is what drives all these companies and entrepreneurs. However, they are not the only players involved. Other spheres mingle with the subject, such as medicine, for example, where doctors have contrary opinions, or men of religion trying to provide answers. 

A complex approach for science

On one side, this subject is very biased in a medical and so more technical point of view. As doctor Pauline Zelli says, “it is a hot topic in our progressive society thanks to improved living conditions and science. However, it should not contribute to increase or create inequalities”. The doctor tells us that advances in science must always be ethically acceptable to the population. The process should not be in detriment of people’s quality of life. She thinks that controlling life expectancy can be acceptable if it does not interfere with individual freedom and if the quality of life is assured. She is aware that increasing life expectancy might imply to make some human body changes. Modifying a human body is never natural but the modification is not always bad, it all depends on the finality of acceptability for the patient (benefit/risk ratio) as she previously said. The ethicality of the process depends on the ultimate purpose of the amendment. If it is to improve living conditions and the transmission or treatment of a serious disease, for example, it may be ethical. It is the responsibility of governments to avoid this (access to care for all, etc…).

A difficult relationship with death

On the other side, the extension of life is also a sensitive subject in religion perspective. In fact, in every religion the death is an important matter for the believers. The monotheistic religions have a paradoxical relationship to immortality. On the one hand there are the founding stories, which tell how death came about. “It is about Adam and Eve being driven out of Eden, the access to the tree of life being blocked on purpose. From now on, the mortal man is the one who knows a deadline, an end and he reflects.” says the rabbi Nissim Sultan who tells us about his vision of death in religion. Philosophy also provides answers on the ethical aspect of death. It is a fundamental determinant; to succeed in life or more exactly to succeed in death (for example with Socrates). The founding stories of the Bible have therefore worked a lot on how death came and what it means. So believers became « comfortable » with the idea of dying. It participates in the energy deployed to make one’s life a success. For Nissim Sultan, immortality is therefore not a research. Paradoxically, on the other hand, these same spiritualities sell the afterlife to believers, the postmortal life. It goes through narratives, through Kabbalah, mysticism, the journeys of the soul, the idea that there is life after death, or the resurrection of the dead. According to Nissim Sultan, the Platonic component as got two principles: the body and the soul: the body disappears the soul always remains. One is then in a search for immortality. So what relation does believers have with the concept of death? According to Nissim Sultan, it is not good for jewish people to say that it is not good not to want to die because it is something that all Jews should seek, and this is much proposed to them in their religion. It may be to console ourselves from death, to transcend it or to overcome it. So the paradox is that either people are comfortable with death, they want to achieve it properly, or death is nothing and not feared, and they want immortality. The idea of death, its concepts and origin, have always interested mankind. It is obviously not moral to wish to die, but it is not necessarily more moral not to want to die. « Life is sacred to all religion, » the rabbi reminds us. Thus, the relationship to death is personal. The rabbi therefore reminds us here that the relationship with death is not obvious to everyone. It has been at the center of preoccupation since the beginning of humanity.

Morals to reflect on life

From a certain angle, increasing life expectancy would help to resolve fears related to death. However, this prolongation of life requires a modification of the body (removal of genes in particular).  Is this going against the natural order? Is it forbidden to modify our body? Can we decide ourselves to extend our life? When we asked the rabbi, he said that there are both schools in Judaism. It is either continuity or sacrilege. The latter school is a minority one and is based on the following foundation: the unnatural. It takes the example of medicine; just because it’s not in nature doesn’t mean it’s not used. The same God who created us, made us with intelligence to produce these technologies to live better and well. As far as the body is concerned, this falls within the scope of everyone’s freedoms. It all depends on whether or not we consider aging to be a disease. If this is the case, then all we do is treat ourselves by increasing our life. This point is very important. Considering aging as a disease and not something natural would make all the debate more ethical. Yes, we are treating ourselves against the disease of aging, as we treat cancer for example. For the lengthening decided of his own free will, he answers that it is a stake of all power, it is necessary that each one has an ethical surveillance on himself. He reminds us that the will to live is not equivalent to omnipotence. So there would be no prohibition in the Jewish religion. Does not prohibiting something make it ethically acceptable? The assertion that there is no religious ban stops here at the fact that there is no text to prohibit it. According to the rabbi, God creates us with a wisdom that allows us to push back certain limits. It will therefore be a relationship to time and to humanity that is different. Indeed, the argument to prevent this improvement would be the equivalent of « it was better before », but it is too light to be a real argument. These issues of transhumanism can be seen in two ways in Jewish religion : “Either we change man in his fundamental structure and as a believer that shocks me because God made me in one way and I am changing God’s plan, or we can think that it is a continuity, we have evolved in a random way and now we are evolving in a planned way. Man induces his own structural changes.” He refers to Darwin’s notions of adaptability and mutations. Under this latter approach, one might then think that it is ethically acceptable to want to live longer. When we said that to the rabbi, he rephrases our question and asks whether it is good or bad to live longer. He refers to Jewish law, the halaha, and asks whether it is a mitzvah (good deed) to live longer. The answer is no, natural time is enough. It is not a duty. So, no ethical problems, but no encouragement either. For him, the ultimate ethical question will be the business plan and the monetization of this desire to live. He reflects on inequalities, those who can afford to live longer and those who cannot. Monetizing life is a dangerous aspect to consider. The well-off would not be sure to live better, because what is the point of living two centuries if everyone dies? Ethical prohibitions may have to be imposed, especially on resources. It is complex to feed our current planet, is it relevant to live longer? There will therefore be a major macroeconomic problem.

The rabbi is probably right. Perhaps we should detach ourselves from the personal and financial aspects to reflect on the common and global interest. What do we want and not what do I want. By including this we, we include all the actors, including those forgotten in these debates. These are the same actors who often fall victim to the limits and excesses caused by those who decide. By taking his points into consideration, we can ask about the limits. We hope not to see the development of black markets for youth with the trade of doses of blood from adolescents, as we already have those for organs. Some statements may also cause concern: Peter Thiel, co-founder of PayPal, is said to be “very interested” in this type of transfusion (but swears that he is not yet “practicing”). Passionate about the subject – and obsessed with his own death – the billionaire invests considerable sums in longevity research and in biotechnology start-ups active in the field of prolonging life. Thus, the beauty of human intelligence could help us defeat diseases and fight many problems in the world. To live longer is not a dream, but something that will soon be accessible. Not rushing blindly and taking into account all aspects seems important. After all, the final decision is yours. Well, to us.


17 986 commentaires

  1. First off I would like to say awesome blog! I had a quick question that I’d like to ask
    if you do not mind. I was interested to know how you center yourself
    and clear your mind prior to writing. I’ve had trouble clearing
    my mind in getting my ideas out. I do enjoy writing but it just seems like the
    first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be lost just trying to
    figure out how to begin. Any ideas or tips? Thank you!

    Also visit my site :: police test; Bruno,

  2. We spent a lot of time at her home. Maybe so her mother could keep an eye on us. Mrs. Spencer made sure to be around, offering drinks, snacks, chit chat. I noticed that she was fairly young herself. Granted at my age, anyone over 25 was old, but she was probably mid-30s, divorced. If she was a indiction of how Carley would develop, maybe I should wait. Mrs. Spencer had fuller breasts and a nice butt. She appeared to be in great shape for her « advanced » age. I knew she was keeping an eye on me as much as I was on her and her younger daughter. Her eldest, Sharon was away at college at the time. With Mrs. Spencer around we mostly limited ourselves to holding hands and sneaking in a few light kisses. One day Mrs. Spencer caught us by surprise walking in as I’d slid my hand up from Carley’s stomach to rub her right breast through her shirt. She didn’t really need a bra yet, so I could feel her nipple, hard, through her shirt. Just this much contact had me hard also.

  3. 635

  4. hey there and thank you for your information ? I have certainly picked up something new from right here.
    I did however expertise a few technical points using this website, as
    I experienced to reload the website many times previous to
    I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your web host is OK?
    Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will very frequently
    affect your placement in google and could damage your high-quality score if
    advertising and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my email and could look out for
    much more of your respective exciting content.
    Make sure you update this again very soon.

    my blog – core exams (Quinn)

  5. Екс-суперник Усика вірить в українця в бою з Джошуа — МЕТА Oleksandr Usyk — Anthony Joshua. Boxing Антъни Джошуа и Александър Усик се изправиха един срещу друг на пресконференция преди двубоя помежду им за световните титли по бокс в тежка категория. На 25 септември двамата ще се бият на

  6. Джошуа зупинить його за 5-7 раундів. Усик почне швидко, а Ентоні буде трохи обачним, бо Олександр – лівша, і він легший. До того ж Джошуа іноді не вистачає впевненості в боях, в яких його можуть Усик – Джошуа: онлайн-трансляція чемпіонського бою Шанси Джошуа на перемогу вищі з однієї причини. Яким би прекрасним боксером не був би Усик, в супертяжах він поки не показав нічого такого, за рахунок чого можна перемогти Джошуа.

  7. Олександр Усик і Ентоні Джошуа взяли участь у відкритому тренуванні напередодні чемпіонського поєдинку в надважкій вазі, який відбудеться 25 вересня у Лондоні, у Мережі з’явилися фото та відео з офіційного заходу JoshuaUsyk Усик показал рекордный вес перед боем с Джошуа (видео

  8. I love your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you create this website yourself or
    did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz respond as I’m looking to design my own blog and would like to know where u got this from.


    Also visit my blog post – study materials (Young)

  9. Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thanks, However I am having difficulties with your RSS.
    I don’t understand the reason why I can’t subscribe to it.
    Is there anyone else getting identical RSS problems? Anyone who knows the answer
    can you kindly respond? Thanks!!

    my site; exam preparation (Niki)

  10. First of all I want to say excellent blog! I had
    a quick question which I’d like to ask if you do not mind.
    I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your
    head prior to writing. I have had a hard time clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts out
    there. I truly do take pleasure in writing however
    it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted just trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or tips?


    Also visit my web-site :: cna certification exam

  11. As an entrepreneur, your customers and your team rely on you to deliver. Try to harness your team’s energy towards your vision and do everything you can to avoid being distracted. A lot of businesses fail once the vision becomes blurry. »
    this blog is great for our country to be a valuable blog and would like to visit you
    visit my site for sure and you will not be good for the good thank you and have a nice day

  12. everyone who wants to pursue life try to visit the site to and you will not regret
    this is the day that all I thought was correct was wrong but when I visited the site I was not in the side because of the usual example I learned
    do not forget that you do not care about the problem the guy does not wanna let them make love to you so that visitor to the site to and you do not repent

  13. Проститутки Тюмени

    Не получаете полноценного удовлетворения через секса с партнершей? Хотите пикантных ощущений, однако ваша девушка не желает пробовать нового? Почувствовать себя любимым и получить сексуальную разрядку ныне весь не сложно: проститутки Тюмени с радостью раздвинут ножки пред каждым, который желает провести вечер максимально продуктивно.
    Проститутки Тюмени

  14. Полис страхования

    Крупнейшая частная российская страховая разряд с универсальным портфелем услуг, включающим вроде комплексные программы защиты интересов бизнеса, беспричинно и широкий спектр страховых продуктов чтобы частных лиц. Уставный капитал компании составляет 15 млрд руб Безусловный руководитель в онлайн-страховании с долей рынка почти 21% 28 лет работы для рынке
    Полис страхования

  15. Вывод из запоя

    Преступление алкоголем зачастую приводит к зависимости, которая перерастает в хроническое и прогрессирующее заболевание. Пьяница систематически ухудшает свое здоровье и перестает узнавать с проблемами повседневной жизни, часто разрушает приманка прежние профессиональные достижения и разрушает семейную жизнь. Однако во многих странах алкоголизм не рассматривается чистый заболевание, требующее профессионального лечения, а точно изображение слабой воли. Некоторый люди не хотят вкушать профессиональной через, потому сколько они связывают реабилитацию и терапию с крайней мерой и источником стыда. Пациенты и их семьи нередко задаются вопросом, наравне лечить алкоголизм в домашних условиях? Однако позволительно ли сам преодолеть неволя и сохранить воздержание без терапии в центре либо клинике?
    Вывод из запоя

  16. пин ап казино

    Ищете лучшие dowel up casino alias привлекательные бонусы? А может, вам просто нужны полезные советы? Какими желание ни были ваши потребности, вы найдете то, что вам надо, на!

    Наши специалисты безвыездно следят ради рынком pin up casino, предоставляя нашим читателям самые свежие акции и привлекательные предложения. Мы тратим обильно времени для тестирование казино, дабы убедиться, что мы рекомендуем единственно лучшие!
    пин ап казино

  17. Заправка картриджей в Харькове

    Мы готовы заправить Ваш картридж в любом районе Харькова и области. Нам дорог круг клиент.

    Работаем вдруг с организациями, так и с частными лицами, по наличному и безналичному расчёту. Заключаем договора на комплексное обслуживание оргтехники (заправка и продажа картриджей, исправление и профилактика).

    Заправка картриджей в Харькове у нас беспричинно дешево оттого, что мы дюже недорого закупаем тонер (масть ради картриджей). Мы делаем это без российских посредников, работая
    Заправка картриджей в Харькове

  18. Hello there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it’s
    truly informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. I?ll appreciate if you
    continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing.

    Feel free to visit my homepage … cna certification exam; Asa,

  19. hello my lovely stopforumspam member

    What are the Types of Loans in Ohio depending on the purpose
    Specific purpose payday loans in Ohio. Funds received in debt may be spent only for a specific purpose specified in the loan agreement.
    Non-purpose loan. The debtor may spend the money received at his discretion.
    Most popular specific purpose payday loans in Ohio are:

    House loan. The most common, of course, is a mortgage when the purchased property acts as collateral for a loan. Sometimes a youth loan is issued, with lighter conditions for debtors. Still quite common is a housing loan that does not imply purchased housing in the form of collateral.
    Car loan – payday loans in Ohio to a car or similar vehicle. The key is often the purchased goods, making the terms of the loan better. Also, loan conditions are improved: car insurance, life and health insurance of the borrower, and receiving a salary to the account of the creditor bank.
    Land loan. To purchase a plot for construction or agricultural activities.
    Consumer. For purchases in modern supermarkets, equipment stores, you can take a personal loan right at the point of sale. Often, specialists located there can contact the bank and get a regular or fast payday loans. Borrowed funds automatically pay for the goods, and the consultant explains when and how to re-pay the debt.
    Educational loan. It is issued to students, as well as to applicants who have passed the competition, to pay for tuition at universities, colleges, etc.
    Broker loan. For the circulation of securities, payday loans in Ohio are issued to an exchange broker, se-curities are purchased securities.
    Others. Objectives not related to those listed, but agreed and approved by the creditor.

  20. Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a 40 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is totally off topic but I had to share it with someone!|

  21. I’m impressed, I have to admit. Rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both equally educative and amusing, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The problem is something not enough men and women are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy I came across this in my search for something relating to this.|

  22. Generally I do not learn post on blogs, however I wish to say that this
    write-up very compelled me to try and do so!
    Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, very nice article.

    my blog post; free study materials (Adolph)